Railway board makes scathing remarks on AC local

Member of Railway Board (rolling stock) inspected various railway facilities in Mumbai a couple of months ago. The notes from this visit have been uploaded on IR’s website. Railway board member has made some harsh remarks about the air conditioned EMU rake which is currently undergoing testing. A short summary of the remarks:

  1. He notes that the rake is badly delayed due to some issues which could not be resolved. He appears to be unhappy with the progress of trials. Thus RDSO and BHEL have been asked to submit the final timeline for commissioning of the rake & also submit detailed schedule of all tests to be carried out on the rake.
  2. ICF has been asked to fix responsibility for manufacturing the rake with 4335 mm height even though max allowed height is 4275 mm on Central Railway
  3. Various deficiencies were noted in the rake with regards to high noise, vibrations, improper interiors & internal furnishings. These issues need to be addressed before pressing the rake into service. Some of the issues are:
    1. Very high level of noise when AC units are switched on. It should be brought down to permissible noise levels
    2. Low height of luggage racks
    3. Projections over seating area due to large size
    4. AC unit height is more than permissible height
    5. Vestibule (portion that allows walking from one coach to other) and floor are at different heights causing uneven flooring
    6. Vestibules are tilting, which creates gap between coaches. Design needs modification
    7. Public information system needs to be more elegant and at a better location
    8. Loose screws were found on flooring & flooring sheets were uneven
    9. Grab handles were broken. A sturdier design needs to be used
    10. Height of grab handles should also be looked into
    11. AC unit in motorman’s cab blows cold air directly on the back of motorman which will be uncomfortable for him
    12. CCTV camera should be provided
    13. LED lights should be used
    14. Number of fans should be reduced and their speed too should be reduced

It looks like the rake has many deficiencies & was hurriedly despatched from ICF. There is still no clarity on when it will be inducted into regular service. That day does seem to be quite far off.

During the inspection of Matunga workshop, Siemens rake motorcoaches too were inspected. Recently CR has been hit by a spate of cracks in bolsters of Siemens EMUs. A bogie bolster is the central section of the bogie that carries the entire weight of a coach on it. Cracks in such a critical component is a safety issue. CR has been working proactively to ensure all rakes are in a condition fit to run. These issues are most probably due to poor manufacturing/quality control at ICF. In his notes, member of board is critical of this as well. He says:

  1. From January 2017 to February 2017, 24 cases of cracks in bolster have been reported. 2 coaches having cracks were inspected
  2. As this is a critical item for safety, ICF was asked to come up with suitable repair procedures quickly. The repairs should be carries out by manufacturer of bogies under supervision of ICF
  3. ICF should trace manufacturer of each defective bolster
  4. RDSO should carry out audit of manufacturing processes of suppliers.
  5. Siemens rakes have started showing high levels of corrosion in various parts of coach in just 6-7 years. ICF should investigate and take corrective action on it.

Overall, this report reflects poorly on ICF. Their quality and finishing have come under criticism from the board. This is nothing new though, as the lack of quality is clearly visible even to the naked eye.

The notes from inspection can be accessed here.


3 thoughts on “Railway board makes scathing remarks on AC local

  1. Ultimately written. I sincerely hope more and more ppl read these facts about the worst quality rakes produced by the Integral Coach Factory in Chennai, in the name of world class rakes.

  2. Stumbled upon this blog and will now remain in my bookmarks forever. Nicely written as VJ said. Appreciate it a lot! In attempts to cut costs, ICF rakes and bogies are causing more and more problems, Not just in Mumbai but around India. Recent derailment of Kaifiyat express was horrible, the coaches really climbed onto one another. And now some severe problems with AC EMU Rakes. I don’t think railway will ever think of requesting a LHB made EMU rake or some sort of that. Siemens rakes are also having problems now. So where are we headed? Mumbai is only going to get more crowded and if things like this continue to happen, I’ll say judgement day will be a lot sooner than later.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s